Wednesday, October 16, 2013

SWE Detroit - Royal Oak Book Club Book Reviews (Sep 2012 - Mar 2013)


Sept 2012 – Bringing Up the Bodies, by Hilary Mantel

Review by Jessica Makäe

This book is a well written, methodical, tale from the perspective of Oliver Cromwell-a pivotal, though non-glamorous figure, in the Henry VIII / Anne Boleyn debacle. The book takes one on the journey through all of Cromwell's machinations to remove Anne, and how his prior experiences played into his actions. I especially enjoyed the descriptions of his time in Italy and his upbringing.  It made him a very thorough and understandable character, if not likeable. 

This is a recent work of historical fiction.  And while it's going to sound illiterate: I just didn't love that this book, while well-written, was a 14 hour audio book that covered what the Showtime series the Tudors covers in the final 2-3 episodes of Season 2 (Max duration: 2 hours).  The book had a lot of extra descriptions that color the time and place, but I don't think that taking Cromwell's perspective on things made the book more interesting than if the author had taken Henry or Anne's perspective.  

Oct 2012 – How to Be a Woman, by Caitlan Moran

Review by Heather

This fearless author tackles numerous topics that are considered taboo in polite conversation, from body hair removal to underwear choice to women’s role in society.  She openly discusses her own life, and it creates a springboard for the readers of this book to feel more comfortable discussing their own lives in ways that they might not previously.  The intended audience is clearly women, but you definitely need to have an open mind regarding the topics she discusses.  Her British dry wit is very entertaining, and brings levity to the book.

Nov 2012 – A Wrinkle in Time, by Madeleine L’Engle

Review by Michele

I found a love of this book and the whole series, having read this many times growing up.  Reading it again as an adult brought up many wonderful memories of the adventures of Meg, Calvin and Charles Wallace.  The story is told by Meg Murry, who is the awkward teenage daughter of two brilliant scientists.  Meg has three brothers, 10 year old popular and athletic twins, Sandy and Dennys, and 5 year old misunderstood genius Charles Wallace.  Mr. Murry went to work on a government project and has not been heard from in quite some time, leaving Mrs. Murry alone with the children.

I enjoyed rereading this book but found it to be a different experience this time through.  I no longer relate with Meg’s awkwardness the way I did when I was younger.  I still enjoyed the fantasy of the story and appreciated it for what it is, a children’s book.  I look forward to sharing this adventure with my future children.

Dec 2012 – The Five Levels of Leadership, by John C. Maxwell

Review by Heather

So, I have a low pain threshold for leadership/professional development books. I've read several, and only a few would I consider worthwhile to actually recommend to others. I would classify this as one of the better ones that I've read, and I think it is relevant to the corporate environment.

The biggest drawback to me was the length of this book. If it had been a 10-20 page article in a magazine, I would have loved it, but I felt like the author provided way more anecdotes than was necessary, and it diluted the effectiveness of the main points.

Jan 2013 – The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks, by Rebecca Skloot

Review by Faith

This was a biographical account of Henrietta Lacks, a poor African American tobacco farmer. In 1951 her cells were taken without her (or her family’s) knowledge, during her treatment for cervical cancer at Johns Hopkins Hospital.  The cells became one of the most important tools in medicine, vital for developing the polio vaccine, cloning, gene mapping, in vitro fertilization, and much more, because of their ability to quickly replicate and continue to survive. Henrietta’s cells have been bought and sold by the billions, yet she remains virtually unknown, and her family can’t even afford health insurance.

The author does an excellent job of writing Henrietta’s story.  She does an incredible amount of research, including getting to know Henrietta’s family.  The research took nearly a decade, so she became pretty integrated into the Lacks family, especially with Henrietta’s daughter Deborah. 

Twenty years after Henrietta’s death, her family began getting calls from scientists who wanted to get blood samples from them to learn more about their family genetics.  Henrietta’s family had no idea her cells had ever been taken.  The author investigates the history of the cells, as well as her family’s desire to get recognition for the societal contribution.

I loved the author’s style of writing this book.  She did a great job incorporating the medical jargon in a friendly way, and wove in the family stories effortlessly. 

Feb 2013 – The Hoarder in You: How to Live a Happier, Healthier, Uncluttered Life, by Robin Zasio

Review by Heather

Do you have too much clutter in your life?  Have you ever thought of why you hold on to things that you don’t use or appreciate?  How much time do you have to spend doing the “care and feeding” of your stuff?  Do you live with a hoarder (from a mere clutterer who has “clutter blindness” to a full-fledged version)?  Do you routinely purchase items you don’t need, and rationalize your purchases because it was on sale or that you might need it for some undefined purpose in the future?  Do you think buying something like a condiment in bulk is useful, if it takes you twenty years to consume it, long past it’s optimal performance?  Then you need to read this book.

I have read the book twice now, and it really opened my eyes with how I had let my “stuff” take over my life, due to some of the reasons above.  I have greatly downsized the amount of clutter I possess, and it literally feels like an enormous weight has been lifted from my life.  I am also finding myself exercising more discipline when I’m shopping, questioning the motive of why I’m considering a purchase, whether it’s a piece of clothing I don’t currently need or food that we won’t consume because our refrigerator is already full of food.  You don’t need to throw away all your possessions, but learning to reclaim your life from over-consumerism will indeed make you happier, as promised by the book’s title.

Mar 2013 – The Hobbit, by J.R.R. Tolkien

Review by Jessica Makäe

This is the story of Bilbo Baggins, a very boring "everyman" hobbit (a comfortable, middle class sort of short pot-bellied humanoid with notably hairy toes) who gets tangled up with an unreliable wizard and a gregarious group of dwarves on a quest to rescue their treasure and homeland from an evil dragon.  All of these things are very counter to hobbit-culture, and he often wishes for the warmth of his own bed, and rues the lack of second breakfasts.  

Over the course of the trek, the group has several adventures and misadventures.  Some of these include wolves, elves, shape shifters, trolls, spiders, orcs, eagles, and Bilbo's fateful encounter with the One Ring - the big lead-up to Tolkein's later books, The Lord of the Rings Trilogy.  I especially enjoyed how Gandalf wove in and out of this book, sometimes showing up to save the day, sometimes parked outside in the 'enemy' camp.  The Hobbit story gives a hint of the complexity of the Gandalf wizard character, while showing remarkable character development in Bilbo Baggins. 

This book is simpler than the Lord of the Rings books.  It's a great introduction to fantasy worlds without having to remember too many unusual creature or place names.  It's a classic, and was arguably the foundation of the fantasy fiction genre.  The Hobbit does seem to have a basis in much older writings, though.  As with some of the Old English / Norse sagas (Orkneyinga saga, Beowulf) the characters often stop to compose a verse of song or poetry.  These may feel like interruptions to the narrative, but I see them as echoes of a much older style of writing.  

I enjoyed this book as an adventure tale, and the realism of returning the characters to their homes / place of origin was a pleasant surprise.  

No comments:

Post a Comment